Compare And Contain: Picking The Best Invisible Fence For You And Your Pet

invisible fence

Last fall I purchased a home beside a lake. Although I was thrilled by the beautiful views of the surroundings and the open space, I faced a dilemma: my land was open-slatted fencing that would not be safe for my dogs.
For the record, I have two black labs, and I have used a 6-foot privacy fence. I love it because it allows me to let the dogs play in the backyard unattended. However, my new place is open and I don't want to obstruct any views both mine or my neighbor's. For this reason, an invisible fence seems like the perfect way to go.
I have heard great things from dog owners who are currently using an invisible fence, specifically, the owner of a Great Dane, the owner of a Chocolate Lab.
I've been researching the many options when it comes to invisible fences brands, and I have 3 options lined up for those of you who are looking for the best invisible dog fences.

I have 3 options lined up for those of you who are looking for the best invisible dog fences.

Top 3 Best Invisible Dog Fences

1. PetSafe Wireless Pet Containment System (PIF-300)

PetSafe Wireless Pet Containment System (PIF-300)

My decision to put PetSafe Wireless Pet Containment System as my first pick of best invisible dog fences mainly because of a large number of positive reviews from other dog owners from amazon (amazon best seller), but also because I loved the fact that it is of excellent quality for the price. Besides, it is portable and easy to install.
I have been using this system for several months and have not ONE negative thing to say about this system!
After reading the instruction manual, I set up the unit and tested it as stated. It worked accordingly.
It has worked really great with my two labs. Training them to learn their boundary took me less than 2 hours, and they don't cross it at all. Even being exited playing catch if the ball rolls out, they just stay at the edge.
Since I purchased this unit, I have enjoyed my dogs to have freedom to run the big yard while keeping them from visiting the neighbors. I Love the flexibility that allows my dogs to come and go with no hassle.

+ Portable - travel with your dog or move
+ Easy to install
+ Durable
+ Waterproof collar - fitting dogs of all sizes: small, medium and large
+ Wide circular range - up to 180 feet in diameter
+ Return within 30 days if not satisfied
- Battery isn’t rechargeable
- Battery issue with the collar - some customers say that the replacement batteries are having a shorter life.

2. PetSafe Stay+Play Wireless Fence

PetSafe Stay+Play Wireless Fence

I decided to put PetSafe Stay+Play Wireless Fence, another top product from PetSafe, as the second best invisible dog fence because it is an upgrade to the PetSafe Wireless Pet Containment System (my number one pick). The major difference is that the collar is smaller and has a rechargeable battery. Besides, the transmitter is 67% smaller that the original ones and covers an extra quarter of an acre.

+ Smaller transmitter
+ Built-in rechargeable battery
+ Portable
+ Accommodates small dog weight (minimum 5 pounds)
- More expensive than number 1 pick
- Coverage is limited for price

3. Havahart® Radial-Shape Select Wireless Dog Fence

Havahart® Radial-Shape Select Wireless Dog Fence

Havahart® Radial-Shape Select Wireless Dog Fence was placed as the third best electric fence for dogs because you can choose either the small dog version or the version for medium or large dogs. Besides, the in-house alert system is a big selling point, since you can always know when your dog is gone astray.

+ Adequate, 400-foot radius from transmitter for owners who live on large space of land
+ Built-in rechargeable battery
+ In-home alert if your dog is gone astray
+ Training flags
+ Waterproof collar
- Warranty: 10 years for the transmitter; 1 year for parts
- Only accommodates two dogs
- Expensive

Wireless Pet Fence Reviews Compared Side-By-Side

Price$259.95$299.95Out of stock
Minimum Dog Weight8 Pounds5 Pounds8 Pounds
Collar Neck Siz6" to 28"6" to 28"12" to 26"
Coverage90 Foot Radius (1/2 Acre)105 Foot Radius (3/4 Acre)400 Foot Radius
Correction Levels555
Tone-Only Mode
Receiver Battery6 VoltRechargeableRechargeable
Maximum Number of DogsUnlimitedUnlimited2
Training Flags Provided505075
Waterproof Collar
Tech SupportMonday-Saturday by Phone and EmailMonday-Saturday by Phone and EmailMonday-Saturday by Phone, Live Chat and Email
WarrantyLifetimeLifetime10 Years Transmitter 1 Year Parts
Return Policy30 Days30 Days30 Days

Why Do You Need An Invisible Fence

1. Invisible fences can be used for puppies 8 weeks or older, as long as they know basic commands such as sit, come, stay.
2. Invisible fence systems can work well in any size yard from 1/4 of an acre to more than 25 acres.

Why do you need an invisible fence?

3. An invisible fence can be placed anywhere, wooden areas, rocky terrain, and even underwater.
4. Invisible fences won't prevent you and your neighbors from enjoying the surrounding views.
5. Invisible fences require much less upkeep. (Speaking from experience, I'm so tired of having to use the weed-wacker on both sides of my privacy fence.)

6. Most invisible fence systems are guaranteed to work with your dog.
QUESTION: I have a very bright dog, will he be able to outsmart the system?
ANSWER: No, he will probably be trained much faster than other dogs.

How An Invisible Fence Works?

How an invisible fence works?

Dogs are typically trained to stay 8 feet from the boundary wire. When they start to get closer to the edge of the property, you will know it is time to change the battery in the fence collar.
Most of the invisible fence includes an audible warning prior to the electric impulse and dogs learn quickly to respect the noise to avoid being corrected. When a dog ignores the audible signal, an electric stimulus is discharged which would startle the dog and the shock sometimes has to be fairly significant and painful.

invisible fence